13- It will be between REV & MTA 14- PSA,Centennial & MTA are all in the same group. Tough draw. 15- Prior Lake is the state cup runner-up and premier league champs. 16- EP but don't count out the REV team. 17- MTA, Burnsville, EP are all very good teams. 18- SSM or SCV
Rev at 15, that's funny! PL lost best player to ECNL. MTA has beefed up a lot. MTA 15 girls have beaten MTA 16 girls in numerous friendlies and have tied 17 MTA girls.
15 Final 4 PL, Cottage Grove, Tonka, MTA Final MTA over PL, but it will be close!
3/8/12 10:41 AM, I think you answered the question wrong. The question that was posted by 3/8/12 10:39 AM was "Will MTA and Shattuck have teams at State Cup??", and the correct answer is YES. MTA will have teams in state cup. Not so sure about Shattuck, but I believe they will as well.
Now, MTA ECNL teams will NOT play in state cup, which you said correctly, but MTA will have teams in state cup.
4:32pm - 10:41 did say that MTA will still have teams in State Cup, "MTA will STILL have some very strong teams THOUGH; U15 and U17. They just didn't spell it out for you! I understood what they were saying that MTA would have still have strong teams and they mentioned that 15 and 17's. And no ECNL teams are not playing.
Shattuck doesn't have any teams playing ECNL, so I'm assuming that the the 17's and 18's will be at State Cup. Shattuck girls are a non-factor and they didn't do anything last year. Average at best this year.
Everyone is picking the logical choices, however, the dark horse in this year's State Cup is TC Fire. They have retooled and are playing very good competition this winter via out of state games and are playing MRL. They have a very winable bracket and could get hot.
I agree with 10:35, the U15 TC Fire girls could really pick up their game and get hot. Don't count out Eden Prairie either at U15. They're a team that has developed nicely over the years and are poised to peak this year!
U-13 will be a REV/MTA final, no other team in MN will be able to catch them this year. Heard they tied in fall scrimmages. Saw one of the MTA teams play over the winter in dome play, small but skilled. REV could be caught by surprise.
So what if there aren't any ECNL teams in State Cup. There's still St. Croix, REV, Eden Prairie and some good MTA teams, etc. MN will be represented well in regionals. FYI, other states also do not have ECNL teams playing their state cups.
I believe that ECNL teams can participate in State Cup. Their schedules will make it hard for them to do so, but there are no laws writen stating they can not participate. Other states will have their ECNL team(s) playing in state cup.
ECNL teams are no longer eligible for State Cup effective this year. This is the 1st year the ECNL will not allow it. So State Cup, Regionals, USYSA Nationals for the girls are now watered down just as it is for the boys. The best youth teams across the nation play in the US Development Academy and the ECNL. It sucks for the US Club Soccer teams and the USYSA teams but it's what US Soccer says is the best for the development of the game in the USA.
3/10/12 4:54 PM - Where is the documentation stating that ECNL teams are not allowed to play in state cup? Wasn't there suppose to be a vote? I would like to see it, if you have it or can point us to it. Thank you.
Can ECNL teams participate in USYS leagues and the USYS state cup, regional, and national championships? Yes. Any team participating in the ECNL may still participate in their local, state and regional leagues, and in the USYS state cup, regional, and national championships. The ECNL is not prohibiting teams from its member clubs from participating in these competitions.
MTA just choses not to have their ECNL teams play. Which means if MTA ECNL teams can't do anything in regionals, NO ONE else will be able to!
While ECNL MTA teams may not participate in State Cup, the blue teams from MTA may in the future. There are many quality players at MTA that may choose not to do ECNL, and play another sport or just remain in the state to play soccer. Don't count out MTA in State Cups.
Now, you just have to figure out how many top players they had, count out most of them or the majority of them or just simply a bunch of them and you will have your answer!
So based on 3/14 , 5:10 we should anticipate SCV and MTA winning a high percentage of the finals.
Doubt it...it looks to be a state cup that has many clubs having success at different ages. I predict no one club will win more than 2 ages...probably a different club at each level.
3/16/12 9:06 AM - No - that person just stated most of the higher level player moved to 2 different clubs. That person also stated REV would not win anything. He or she did NOT say anything about MTA or SCV winning a high percentage.
The good Rev players went to MTA ECNL teams and will not be at State Cup. MTA will still win a few titles on both boys and girls side. But without their DAP and ECNL teams they will not dominate like the past 7 or 8 years. I will predict MTA will win 5 title, SCV 3, PSA 2, BHK 2, MU 2...nobody else will win more than one.
Here are the facts. Three current u 14 players went to mta one was a good player but not a hard worker one was a starter but replaceable the third did not start or play much No other players left for mta or any other club their biggest loss is the player that tore her acl this winter. One player left for St croix at 16 but she has since quit. Two 18 rev players went to St croix 17 to play their own age all rev teams 13-16 are better than last year even the 14 if healthy. They all added talent from the outside but no team added more talent than the 18s. But more important is that they have all trained 2-3 times a week and had a lot of full field scrimmages with very good results.
Does not mean they win a game but I like their chances in two months we will know.
In two months we will know what club has the most success at state cup my money will be on rev especially since all their teams have good draws as well
Does anyone know if MTA is organized as a nonprofit or for profit company? I figured it was nonprofit but can't find it listed on the Attorney General's site.
It appears MTA is a non-profit organization according to Minnesota Secretary of State. http://mblsportal.sos.state.mn.us/Business/SearchDetails/1E-801?status=Active&itemType=Nonprofit%20Corporation%20%28Domestic%29
@1:19 Thanks rev mom who's daughter didn't make MTA. Clearly you need this blog for self affirmation to convince yourself and others that everything will be ok...which of course it will. This is just youth soccer.
So some believe that Rev will have a big year on the girls side. They won no title last year and made 1 final...hmmm. They probably do have decent chance at 16s, EDP and SCV both have good teams. I can't see any other good opportunities for Rev. But of course games aren't played on this blog, they are played on the field where anything can happen.
13 MTE vs REV 14 All premier teams in A and B and none in C or D which is too bad. Winner will come out of A - CNS. 15 PL vs MTA 16 DKT vs EDP 17 MTA vs WYZ 18 MTA vs SCV
The Wayzata girls that made the Tonka team did not make the MTA team. Not to take anything away from them because they're good players. Edina, really? I don't see that Tonka got that much help for them to make a big difference at 15.
Whoever said PL at U15 is overrated hasn't done their homework. Last year they were state cup runner up and went 7-1-2 winning the Premier league. They won the league going away. In fact, they lost their first league game and were undefeated in the next 9. They are the clear favorites until someone knocks them off. They are extremely well coached and will out work any team.
10:29pm Thanks KO. But we lost one of our best players to MTA. The girls are overworked and extremely burned out. Time will tell though if they can be a success.
SCV 18's are a good team and won't be challenged much until regionals. Minnesota is viewed within the region as being very competitive at this age level, so hopefully they can be ready to make a deep push at regionals again. It doesn't look like they are playing MRL, so hopefully they will doing something more than just league to get prepared for regional competition.
Interesting info on the SVC 18's. They may not all have signed at D1 schools, but its a pretty impressive list overall. Can any club claim to have done better?
12:35 - Thanks, I didn't realize Rev had so many as well. I find this very interesting as the only one who seems to get publicity for college signees is MTA. Seems likes there's a lot more out there ...
This is coming from an MTA parent. I'm happy that we're seeing so many girls from multiple clubs moving on to play college soccer. It shows that MN is making great strides in women's soccer. Congratulations to everyone!
13 - Agree 14 - CNS - REV might make it to semi's 15 - PRL or MTA - REV doesn't have a chance and won't make the semi's 16 - Agree 17 - WYZ or EP 18 SCV
Is there anything preventing a MTA ECNL player from joining one of these teams in State Cup? If not, I know of at least one U17 player who will plans to play with SCV.
Nothing prevents players from dual rostering on a US Club (ECNL) team and a USYSA team (State Cup). As long as they were registered in time and appear on the roster they are eligible.
MTA ECNL does roster players from other clubs. There's no rules against that. Those players will go back to their club to play State Cup. It's not just one girl, it's a few girls at all age levels. Nothing illegal about it and remember ECNL teams can play in their State Cups. MTA just chooses not to.
Tough weekend for Minnesota teams in Vegas this past weekend, looks like we went 10-27-3 for the ten MN teams there. No teams emerging as state cup favorites based on results.
Next big pre-state checkpoints will be the MRL and OH/Indy events in April.
It's hard to determine "State Cup favorites" when they play out of state teams? And in most cases teams they've never played before. Same can be said for MRL an OH/Indy. Although some age brackets at MRL do have multiple MN teams so maybe something will come out of that? There's about 3-4 favorites in every age group at State Cup and any team could come out on top! Alot will depend on injuries, who's "on" that day, etc.
A "state cup favorite" would be a team that can go outside of the state and win consistently, with the goal to win state cup decisively to get ready for regionals, make a deep run at regionals and go to the national tournament. The goal is much bigger than just winning state cup.
Well no MN team goes outside of the state and win consistently. So are you saying that winning state cup doesn't really matter in the end and why bother if MN teams can't win outside of the state.
You can't expect to go to CA and win consistently when they play outside/full field all year. We are just coming out from all winter indoors. That is a factor. MN teams do better when they go to CA later in our season.
Not seeing many MN teams that did really well. MTA 16's played in a lower bracket and won 2 games. That's the same team that was relegated this past year. The only reason they're premier is because they took the ECNL teams premier spot. MTA 16's won't do anything and will most likely be on the bottom of the standings come July.
PSA is emerging as a fairly competetive club. They've slowly taken kids from the west side (MTA, old Wings players) that don't want to pay all that MTA money and drive to all parts of the Twin Cities for training. They have premier teams on the girls side at 14, 16 and 17. Many of the girls came from MTA!
Lots of Rev boosters . 16's are only team with a chance. 13's are a mess ,very talented but half the team is shopping for next year. 14's good but not dominant. 15's not close to pl or tonka 16's strong team but EP and MTA second team (Blue) very strong too 17's REV out 18's Rev 1 is good but st Croix is team to beat.
13 - Rev, but MTA could win this. 14 - Centennial, MUS could surprise 15 - PL overrated, Tonka will surprise. 16 - EP, but REV could make a run 17 - Burnsville, but MTA could surprise 18 - SSM
Not sure how PL can be called "overrated" since they are the state cup runner up and Premier league champion? Other than the top MTA team they have won more games than anyone else in the u15 age group.
Prior Lake is overrated. They lost their best player and can't function without her. PL got lucky last year due to other teams with numerous injuries. U15 Premier Standings for this year; Tonka, MTA, Prior Lake, Rev, Cottage Grove, NSS
PL is a very good, balanced TEAM. To think any one of the players was head and shoulders above the others shows a definite lack of knowledge of the team.
11:03pm. How would you define balanced? Because I really don't see that from our team, unfair yes. I don't think players should have to be afraid of every step they make. That's not building a balanced team! That's building a team that will fall apart!
Here's my take on the girls side. Agree or disagree?
13's MTA - don't know too much about 13's 14's PSA - This could go to CNS 15's MTA - Very improved team from last year 16's EP - could go REV's way 17's BSVL - MTA might make a run 18's SCV
What about PSA 16's? They did well in Vegas (better than EP, REV and MTA). PSA and MTA had six goals for during the tournament. EP and REV only managed 3 and 2 goals for, yet are favorites? This age looks wide open, and dont count out SCV.
Back to the Las Vegas tournament for a second, how does anyone know the top flights and the bottom flights (A and B flights)? Are you guessing because of the way the schedules are laid out on the web page? It looks to be alphabetical to me. And if that was the case, MTA and Rev are closer to the top – so does that mean they played higher ranked or better teams? Just wondering how people are coming to the conclusions. I am also asking based on what 3/27/12 10:15 PM posted.
Look at the flights and the ranking of the teams. The brackets listed first had higher ranked teams in their state, region and national. The brackets further down had lower ranked teams in their state, region and national. But the GotSoccer rankings are a whole other "can of worms!"
Hate to dwell in this, but 2:44 your wrong. The #1 teams from UT,NV and OR were in the fourth bracket. Dont try to figure it out or even justify it...Good teams were playing in every bracket. Other than the first bracket which had a few elite teams (top 10 nat'l) the tourn people tried to spread out the competition.
I don't care! I'm just happy MN teams played well in Vegas! I want to talk about State Cup, not some tournament in Las Vegas. Go to the Girls Club tab.
LOL! 4/4/12 12:38 PM here, sorry, I didn't mean to stir up such a fuss. I was just curious. OK, back to state cup.
I have noticed that no one has mentioned Cottage Grove or TC Fire. Cottage Grove was one of the last 4 teams in the state cup semi finals for U14 (current U15 this year). 2 MTA teams, PL and CG.
2:08pm Here. I don't care if 3:16pm thinks I'm silly. And I don't think they're a bully. Maybe I'm silly or maybe I'm completely off my rocker, but MTA will win 13, 15 and 17.
3:50, you are correct. It appeared as if I was being a bully. I should have said that I think their position/belief (that MTA will win 13, 15, and 17) is silly-thanks.
9:42am. I respect your opinion, but I'm curious who do you think will win those age groups and why.
Here's my reason why I think MTA will win 15 & 17.
15 MTA - semi's last year, lost to PL 2-1. The team is stronger tha they've ever been. Played their ECNL team to a 0-0 game for most of the game, but lost 1-0 late in the game when SB powered one in.
17 MTA - picked up a few players from the TCF team that went to semi's last year. Also stronger than they've ever been.
the coaches from mta ecnl teams don't care about state cup. They will not come back until girls stop showing up at tryouts. Until then they could care less (and this is from a mta parent!)
Not taking anything away from NSSA, but I don't think they have a snowball's chance in hell. It's great that they moved up to the premier league, but now they're playing much bigger, stronger and faster teams than they played at C1 in the north league.
Semi #1 (TCF vs. BVL): TCF Semi #2 (WYZ vs. EDP): WYZ
Final (TCF vs. WYZ): TCF
SCV could be a dark horse in the B bracket though, we'll see how they fair in MRL and maybe I'll change my picks. Nice to see so many of these teams playing MRL, makes for a better state cup tournament instead of coming in cold.
Tonka 15s will struggle unless they make some position changes. They have their best play makers playing defense when they should be playing in the mid or attack.
I love it -- do parents really think that by venting on a blog they will get their way? Try talking to your kid's coach about it, that just might be a bit more effective and enlightening for you! But, good luck with it, I'm sure your coach is an avid reader of this blog and will adjust his/her system as soon as possible.
For the 15's don't under estimate anyone it could very well be and of the 5 most talented teams who are very well matched. It could either be MTA, PL, Tonka, Rev, or Cottage Grove. With out the ECNL MTA's this year it's anyones game.
Chat: 2012 Girls State Cup
ReplyDeleteThank you!
ReplyDeleteWill MTA and Shattuck have teams at State Cup??
ReplyDeleteNo,not ECNL teams. MTA will still have some very strong teams though; U15 and U17.
ReplyDeletePredictions for U13 & U14 age groups?
ReplyDelete13 - Rev
ReplyDelete14 - Centennial
15 - MTA
16 - EP
17 - MTA
18 - SCV
13- REV
ReplyDelete14- PSA
15- REV
16- MTA
17- MTA
18- SCV
13- It will be between REV & MTA
ReplyDelete14- PSA,Centennial & MTA are all in the same group. Tough draw.
15- Prior Lake is the state cup runner-up and premier league champs.
16- EP but don't count out the REV team.
17- MTA, Burnsville, EP are all very good teams.
18- SSM or SCV
Rev at 15, that's funny! PL lost best player to ECNL. MTA has beefed up a lot. MTA 15 girls have beaten MTA 16 girls in numerous friendlies and have tied 17 MTA girls.
ReplyDelete15 Final 4
PL, Cottage Grove, Tonka, MTA
Final MTA over PL, but it will be close!
with mta ecnl out...mta will find it difficult to post the same kind of dominence.
ReplyDelete13- ? anything can happen at this age...many first timers
14-Cen
15-PL
16-EP
17-Burns
18-scv
2:30...MTA at 16 & 17(really?)
ReplyDeleteNo way MTA at 16! Not a good team!
ReplyDelete13's too early.
14 - Centennial
15 - Tonka
16 - EP
17 - Wayzata
18 - SCV
3/8/12 10:41 AM, I think you answered the question wrong. The question that was posted by 3/8/12 10:39 AM was "Will MTA and Shattuck have teams at State Cup??", and the correct answer is YES. MTA will have teams in state cup. Not so sure about Shattuck, but I believe they will as well.
ReplyDeleteNow, MTA ECNL teams will NOT play in state cup, which you said correctly, but MTA will have teams in state cup.
4:32pm - 10:41 did say that MTA will still have teams in State Cup, "MTA will STILL have some very strong teams THOUGH; U15 and U17. They just didn't spell it out for you! I understood what they were saying that MTA would have still have strong teams and they mentioned that 15 and 17's.
ReplyDeleteAnd no ECNL teams are not playing.
Shattuck doesn't have any teams playing ECNL, so I'm assuming that the the 17's and 18's will be at State Cup. Shattuck girls are a non-factor and they didn't do anything last year. Average at best this year.
ReplyDelete3/8/12 4:59 PM - who cares! The main point, MTA will have teams in State Cup, which is what was asked.
ReplyDeleteEveryone is picking the logical choices, however, the dark horse in this year's State Cup is TC Fire. They have retooled and are playing very good competition this winter via out of state games and are playing MRL. They have a very winable bracket and could get hot.
ReplyDeleteFor the 10:35 comment - I meant to say TC Fire for U15!
ReplyDeleteI agree with 10:35, the U15 TC Fire girls could really pick up their game and get hot. Don't count out Eden Prairie either at U15. They're a team that has developed nicely over the years and are poised to peak this year!
ReplyDeleteDon't forget about PSA & Rev for 14s. They are both quality teams and could make an impact too.
ReplyDeleteU-13 will be a REV/MTA final, no other team in MN will be able to catch them this year. Heard they tied in fall scrimmages. Saw one of the MTA teams play over the winter in dome play, small but skilled. REV could be caught by surprise.
ReplyDelete10:57am. Seriously Eden Prairie at U15! That is almost laughable. It's going to be either Prior Lake or MTA. Way too stong of teams for EP to compete!
ReplyDeleteRev has a strong team in that mix at 13s,14s,15s & 16s.
ReplyDeleteMaybe 4 State Cup Championships?
11:20 maybe Rev at 13's and 16's, but no other ages.
ReplyDeleteWith no ECNL teams this is *hardly* a state championship anymore.
ReplyDelete1:34, mta made the choice not partipate...and now you want to say its not a state championship. that is the statement of a loser!
ReplyDeletethe winner of the state cup will move on to regionals and represent MN in the same manor as those teams in the past.
good luck to all!
So what if there aren't any ECNL teams in State Cup. There's still St. Croix, REV, Eden Prairie and some good MTA teams, etc. MN will be represented well in regionals. FYI, other states also do not have ECNL teams playing their state cups.
ReplyDeleteI believe that ECNL teams can participate in State Cup. Their schedules will make it hard for them to do so, but there are no laws writen stating they can not participate. Other states will have their ECNL team(s) playing in state cup.
ReplyDeleteECNL teams are no longer eligible for State Cup effective this year.
ReplyDeleteThis is the 1st year the ECNL will not allow it.
So State Cup, Regionals, USYSA Nationals for the girls are now watered down just as it is for the boys.
The best youth teams across the nation play in the US Development Academy and the ECNL.
It sucks for the US Club Soccer teams and the USYSA teams but it's what US Soccer says is the best for the development of the game in the USA.
3/10/12 4:54 PM - Where is the documentation stating that ECNL teams are not allowed to play in state cup? Wasn't there suppose to be a vote? I would like to see it, if you have it or can point us to it. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteSorry - I meant 3/11/12 5:39 PM - where is the information.
ReplyDeleteECNL teams are playing in other states...
ReplyDeleteFROM ECNL Site:
ReplyDeleteCan ECNL teams participate in USYS leagues and the USYS state cup, regional, and national championships?
Yes. Any team participating in the ECNL may still participate in their local, state and regional leagues, and in the USYS state cup, regional, and national championships. The ECNL is not prohibiting teams from its member clubs from participating in these competitions.
MTA just choses not to have their ECNL teams play. Which means if MTA ECNL teams can't do anything in regionals, NO ONE else will be able to!
MTA cannot (or are choosing not to) play in state cup because ECNL nationals are the week of June 25th and Regional’s are that same week.
ReplyDeletewhen will the pool play be posted?
ReplyDeleteseems quiet compared to years past?
While ECNL MTA teams may not participate in State Cup, the blue teams from MTA may in the future. There are many quality players at MTA that may choose not to do ECNL, and play another sport or just remain in the state to play soccer. Don't count out MTA in State Cups.
ReplyDelete"Anybody wondering if maybe the MTA ECNL parents were the ones making all the posts??????"
ReplyDeleteNo, but usually it is true.
MTA won't win one age group. REV will be the club that comes out on top with the most champions.
ReplyDeleteREV will be lucky to get to any finals. Most of their top players have moved to MTA or SCV.
ReplyDeletePlease define "MOST"...is that one or two players?
ReplyDelete"Most" means almost all of them, like the "majority" of them. A bunch of them.
ReplyDeleteNow, you just have to figure out how many top players they had, count out most of them or the majority of them or just simply a bunch of them and you will have your answer!
ReplyDeleteSo based on 3/14 , 5:10 we should anticipate SCV and MTA winning a high percentage of the finals.
ReplyDeleteDoubt it...it looks to be a state cup that has many clubs having success at different ages. I predict no one club will win more than 2 ages...probably a different club at each level.
I agree with 9:06am, it's wide open this year!
ReplyDelete3/16/12 9:06 AM - No - that person just stated most of the higher level player moved to 2 different clubs. That person also stated REV would not win anything. He or she did NOT say anything about MTA or SCV winning a high percentage.
ReplyDeleteThe good Rev players went to MTA ECNL teams and will not be at State Cup. MTA will still win a few titles on both boys and girls side. But without their DAP and ECNL teams they will not dominate like the past 7 or 8 years. I will predict MTA will win 5 title, SCV 3, PSA 2, BHK 2, MU 2...nobody else will win more than one.
ReplyDeleteHere are the facts. Three current u 14 players went to mta one was a good player but not a hard worker one was a starter but replaceable the third did not start or play much No other players left for mta or any other club their biggest loss is the player that tore her acl this winter.
ReplyDeleteOne player left for St croix at 16 but she has since quit. Two 18 rev players went to St croix 17 to play their own age all rev teams 13-16 are better than last year even the 14 if healthy. They all added talent from the outside but no team added more talent than the 18s. But more important is that they have all trained 2-3 times a week and had a lot of full field scrimmages with very good results.
Does not mean they win a game but I like their chances in two months we will know.
In two months we will know what club has the most success at state cup my money will be on rev especially since all their teams have good draws as well
Rev won't win at 15!
ReplyDeleteDoes anyone know if MTA is organized as a nonprofit or for profit company? I figured it was nonprofit but can't find it listed on the Attorney General's site.
ReplyDeleteIt appears MTA is a non-profit organization according to Minnesota Secretary of State.
ReplyDeletehttp://mblsportal.sos.state.mn.us/Business/SearchDetails/1E-801?status=Active&itemType=Nonprofit%20Corporation%20%28Domestic%29
Why do you ask 9:11pm?
ReplyDelete@1:19 Thanks rev mom who's daughter didn't make MTA. Clearly you need this blog for self affirmation to convince yourself and others that everything will be ok...which of course it will. This is just youth soccer.
ReplyDeleteSo some believe that Rev will have a big year on the girls side. They won no title last year and made 1 final...hmmm. They probably do have decent chance at 16s, EDP and SCV both have good teams. I can't see any other good opportunities for Rev. But of course games aren't played on this blog, they are played on the field where anything can happen.
ReplyDeleteRev - No
ReplyDeleteMTA - NO
SCV - No
The teams to watch out for are PSA! That's the club that will come out with the most champions!
If the draw allows for it these will be the championship games.
ReplyDelete13 REV vs MTA
14 PSA vs Centenial
15 Tonka vs PL
16 EP vs REV
17 Wayzatta vs Burnsville
18 St Croix vs REV
13 Rev vs MTA
ReplyDelete14 MUS vs Centennial
15 PL vs MTA
16 EP vs Rev
17 Wayzata vs MTA
18 St. Croix vs ????
Depending on how brackets were drawn.
U15 Girls
ReplyDeleteBracket A
Prior Lake
Dakota Rev C1
Wayzata
play in game (Woodbury vs Maplebrook)
Bracket B
Cottage grove
Burnsville
Dakota Rev premier
Minneapolis United
Bracket C
MN Thunder North
St. Croix
Eden Prairie
North Suburban
Bracket D
Centennial
Tonka
Mahtomedi
Twin Cities Fire
Concerning 15's.
ReplyDeleteA plays D and B plays C in semi's.
Final Tonka vs MTA.
9:30am said Tonka vs PL. 1:37pm said Tonka vs MTA. Maybe the same person, maybe not. Either way they like Tonka at 15!
ReplyDeleteBrackets are up!
ReplyDelete13 MTE vs REV
ReplyDelete14 All premier teams in A and B and none in C or D which is too bad. Winner will come out of A - CNS.
15 PL vs MTA
16 DKT vs EDP
17 MTA vs WYZ
18 MTA vs SCV
Winners
ReplyDelete13 - MTE
14 - CNS
15 - TNK
16 - EDP
17 - WYZ
18 - SCV
No disrespect to Minnetonka 15s but they were 4th in Premier League last season. Why the high expectations this spring?
ReplyDeleteWayzata finished in last place. Again, no disrespect intended. Edina wasn't Premier.
ReplyDeleteThe Wayzata girls that made the Tonka team did not make the MTA team. Not to take anything away from them because they're good players. Edina, really? I don't see that Tonka got that much help for them to make a big difference at 15.
ReplyDeleteTonka played this past weekend against the u16 Rev team and looked pretty good.
ReplyDeleteI predict EP will win the U19 championship.
ReplyDeleteTough draw for the U17's, championship game basically being played on the first day.
ReplyDeleteTough draw for 14's too!
ReplyDeleteWhoever said PL at U15 is overrated hasn't done their homework. Last year they were state cup runner up and went 7-1-2 winning the Premier league. They won the league going away. In fact, they lost their first league game and were undefeated in the next 9. They are the clear favorites until someone knocks them off. They are extremely well coached and will out work any team.
ReplyDelete10:29pm Thanks KO. But we lost one of our best players to MTA. The girls are overworked and extremely burned out. Time will tell though if they can be a success.
ReplyDelete10:40am Not what I heard, but ok if that what makes you feel better.
ReplyDeleteWhy so much interest in 15's?
ReplyDelete17's Wayzata, MTA, Rev, TCF? Didn't a bunch of girls leave the TCF premier team?
ReplyDeleteWho cares if Wayzata girls left for Tonka. Wayzata was relegated, so they couldn't have been that great!
ReplyDelete2:45 PM -- We do and notwithstanding the post of 10:29 PM, the league was pretty competitive without any team dominating.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteNow back to soccer!
ReplyDelete13 MTA
14 CNS
15 REV
16 EDP
17 WYZ
18 SCV
Final Four - Ages 13-17. Agree or disagree, but let's see if we can lead this blog back to a state cup discussion.
ReplyDelete13's - DKT, MTE, MTE, MUS
14's - CNS, MUS, SCV, EAG
15's - PRL, CTG, MTN, TNK
16's - DKT, EDP, SCV, PSA
17's - MTE, WYZ, EDP, BVL
SCV 18's are a good team and won't be challenged much until regionals. Minnesota is viewed within the region as being very competitive at this age level, so hopefully they can be ready to make a deep push at regionals again. It doesn't look like they are playing MRL, so hopefully they will doing something more than just league to get prepared for regional competition.
ReplyDeleteInteresting info on the SVC 18's. They may not all have signed at D1 schools, but its a pretty impressive list overall. Can any club claim to have done better?
ReplyDeleteMaybe not as impressive as St Croix but still okay.
ReplyDeletehttp://www.dakotarev.org/page/show/462673-varsity-recognition
12:35 - Thanks, I didn't realize Rev had so many as well. I find this very interesting as the only one who seems to get publicity for college signees is MTA. Seems likes there's a lot more out there ...
ReplyDeleteThis is coming from an MTA parent. I'm happy that we're seeing so many girls from multiple clubs moving on to play college soccer. It shows that MN is making great strides in women's soccer.
ReplyDeleteCongratulations to everyone!
Well said 2:57 and I couldn't agree more!
ReplyDeleteAnyone have any guess as to how many girls got D1 scholarships this year?
ReplyDeleteIs the answer all of them?
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteOk back to State Cup. Really no one has any predictions, good or bad?
ReplyDeleteBurnsville is going to run away with the U17 title this year!
ReplyDeleteMaybe 3:25pm. I tend to lean towards MTA or WYZ.
ReplyDeleteI don't know if BV will "run away with it" but I would bet they win it.
ReplyDeletePrior Lake is going to run away with every age group they play!
ReplyDelete13-Rev- Very talented group in this age. Might be the best REV team to ever play at 13.
ReplyDeleteFinalist-MTA
14-Rev- Strong C1 team. They just missed out on premiere last season but are playing quality soccer. Impressed against MTA ECNL.
Finalist-PSA
15-PRL- I heard that they lost a couple of their best players but they are still the favorites to win.
Finalist-REV
16-Rev- This team is loaded! They also have a quality coach.
Finalist-EP
17-BV- Best player in the state plays on this team. She is tough to stop.
Finalist-Way or EP
18-Scv- With MTA out of the way, they should take it down.
Finalist- Eagan
4:05pm Clearing a REV parent?
ReplyDelete13 - Agree
14 - CNS - REV might make it to semi's
15 - PRL or MTA - REV doesn't have a chance and won't make the semi's
16 - Agree
17 - WYZ or EP
18 SCV
Is there anything preventing a MTA ECNL player from joining one of these teams in State Cup? If not, I know of at least one U17 player who will plans to play with SCV.
ReplyDeleteNothing prevents players from dual rostering on a US Club (ECNL) team and a USYSA team (State Cup). As long as they were registered in time and appear on the roster they are eligible.
ReplyDeleteMTA ECNL does roster players from other clubs. There's no rules against that. Those players will go back to their club to play State Cup. It's not just one girl, it's a few girls at all age levels. Nothing illegal about it and remember ECNL teams can play in their State Cups. MTA just chooses not to.
ReplyDeleteMTA choses not to because of the schedule conflict.
ReplyDeletechose or chooses
ReplyDeleteHath chosen
ReplyDeleteChose and chooses. Hath chosen works as well!
ReplyDeleteMTA's ECNL teams hath chosen nay to partake in said state cup geflit
ReplyDeleteTough weekend for Minnesota teams in Vegas this past weekend, looks like we went 10-27-3 for the ten MN teams there. No teams emerging as state cup favorites based on results.
ReplyDeleteNext big pre-state checkpoints will be the MRL and OH/Indy events in April.
It's hard to determine "State Cup favorites" when they play out of state teams? And in most cases teams they've never played before. Same can be said for MRL an OH/Indy. Although some age brackets at MRL do have multiple MN teams so maybe something will come out of that?
ReplyDeleteThere's about 3-4 favorites in every age group at State Cup and any team could come out on top! Alot will depend on injuries, who's "on" that day, etc.
For sure it's much more wide open than its ever been now that the ECNL teams aren't participating.
ReplyDeleteA "state cup favorite" would be a team that can go outside of the state and win consistently, with the goal to win state cup decisively to get ready for regionals, make a deep run at regionals and go to the national tournament. The goal is much bigger than just winning state cup.
ReplyDeleteWell no MN team goes outside of the state and win consistently. So are you saying that winning state cup doesn't really matter in the end and why bother if MN teams can't win outside of the state.
ReplyDeleteYou can't expect to go to CA and win consistently when they play outside/full field all year. We are just coming out from all winter indoors. That is a factor. MN teams do better when they go to CA later in our season.
ReplyDeleteThe one MTA girls team won more than they lost in the Las Vegas event...just saying!
ReplyDeleteNot seeing many MN teams that did really well. MTA 16's played in a lower bracket and won 2 games. That's the same team that was relegated this past year. The only reason they're premier is because they took the ECNL teams premier spot. MTA 16's won't do anything and will most likely be on the bottom of the standings come July.
ReplyDeleteMta 14s lost three
ReplyDeleteLas Vegas,
ReplyDeleteWayzata, EP, Lakeville 17's all had NO wins.
16's PSA won 3 games! MTA & REV - 2 wins, EP - 1 win.
15's Tonka and Prior Lake 1 win each.
14's MTA - NO wins
State Cup Winners
ReplyDelete13's MTA
14's Centennial
15's Tonka
16's REV
17's Burnsville
Whats with the PSA 16 team?
ReplyDeletePSA is emerging as a fairly competetive club. They've slowly taken kids from the west side (MTA, old Wings players) that don't want to pay all that MTA money and drive to all parts of the Twin Cities for training. They have premier teams on the girls side at 14, 16 and 17. Many of the girls came from MTA!
ReplyDeleteExactly 6:04pm! Besides ECNL teams couldn't win at regions, no one else will be able to!
ReplyDeleteOn the PSA PR16's - the core has been PSA for several years. They added a few girls who played Edina premier last year.
ReplyDeleteLots of Rev boosters . 16's are only team with a chance.
ReplyDelete13's are a mess ,very talented but half the team is shopping for next year.
14's good but not dominant.
15's not close to pl or tonka
16's strong team but EP and MTA second team (Blue) very strong too
17's REV out
18's Rev 1 is good but st Croix is team to beat.
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete13 REV
ReplyDelete14 PSA
15 PL
16 REV
17 St Croix
18 SSM
13 - Rev, but MTA could win this.
ReplyDelete14 - Centennial, MUS could surprise
15 - PL overrated, Tonka will surprise.
16 - EP, but REV could make a run
17 - Burnsville, but MTA could surprise
18 - SSM
Not sure how PL can be called "overrated" since they are the state cup runner up and Premier league champion? Other than the top MTA team they have won more games than anyone else in the u15 age group.
ReplyDeletePrior Lake is overrated. They lost their best player and can't function without her. PL got lucky last year due to other teams with numerous injuries.
ReplyDeleteU15 Premier Standings for this year;
Tonka, MTA, Prior Lake, Rev, Cottage Grove, NSS
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteWhy isn't anyone picking MTA for u15?
ReplyDeletePl lost their best player to MTA.
ReplyDeleteYes, we (PL) did lose ONE of our better players to MTA, but were still very strong.
ReplyDeletePL is a very good, balanced TEAM. To think any one of the players was head and shoulders above the others shows a definite lack of knowledge of the team.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDelete11:03pm. How would you define balanced? Because I really don't see that from our team, unfair yes. I don't think players should have to be afraid of every step they make. That's not building a balanced team! That's building a team that will fall apart!
ReplyDelete15 State Cup Finalist
ReplyDeleteRev will beat PL and Tonka will beat MTA in semi's.
REV vs Tonka - Champ Tonka!
You heard it here first!
Rev might not make it out of pool play at 15's. Tonka looks to be a good contender, along with PL and MTA. My guess is tonka
ReplyDeletewhy the silence out there?
ReplyDeleteOk, I'll say something.
ReplyDeleteHere's my take on the girls side. Agree or disagree?
13's MTA - don't know too much about 13's
14's PSA - This could go to CNS
15's MTA - Very improved team from last year
16's EP - could go REV's way
17's BSVL - MTA might make a run
18's SCV
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteWhat about PSA 16's? They did well in Vegas (better than EP, REV and MTA). PSA and MTA had six goals for during the tournament. EP and REV only managed 3 and 2 goals for, yet are favorites? This age looks wide open, and dont count out SCV.
ReplyDeleteI'll give you PSA at 16's. They do have a chance.
ReplyDeleteEP played very good teams in Vegas.
ReplyDeleteRumor has it that MTA and REV where short players due to injuries.
PSA had a good tournament and beat some high ranked teams congrats to them.
16 should be a fun age group to follow with 5 teams in the mix.
The team that stays healthy and is able to play well when it matters will come out on top.
13 mta vs rev
ReplyDelete14 psa vs centennial
15 tonka vs pl
16 rev vs psa
17 mta vs Burnsville
18 ssm vs rev
13 MTA over REV
ReplyDelete14 Centennial over MUS
15 MTA over PL
16 REV over PSA
17 BVL over PSA
18 SCV over MTA
Back to the Las Vegas tournament for a second, how does anyone know the top flights and the bottom flights (A and B flights)? Are you guessing because of the way the schedules are laid out on the web page? It looks to be alphabetical to me. And if that was the case, MTA and Rev are closer to the top – so does that mean they played higher ranked or better teams? Just wondering how people are coming to the conclusions. I am also asking based on what 3/27/12 10:15 PM posted.
ReplyDeleteLas Vegas is done or go over to the Girls Club news tab and rehash. This string is about MN State Cup.
ReplyDeletethere is no A or B flights in that showcase. look at any bracket and there were quality teams.
ReplyDeleteLook at the flights and the ranking of the teams. The brackets listed first had higher ranked teams in their state, region and national. The brackets further down had lower ranked teams in their state, region and national. But the GotSoccer rankings are a whole other "can of worms!"
ReplyDeleteHate to dwell in this, but 2:44 your wrong. The #1 teams from UT,NV and OR were in the fourth bracket. Dont try to figure it out or even justify it...Good teams were playing in every bracket. Other than the first bracket which had a few elite teams (top 10 nat'l) the tourn people tried to spread out the competition.
ReplyDeleteNow back to state cup.....
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI don't care! I'm just happy MN teams played well in Vegas! I want to talk about State Cup, not some tournament in Las Vegas. Go to the Girls Club tab.
ReplyDeleteNow back to State Cup.......
LOL! 4/4/12 12:38 PM here, sorry, I didn't mean to stir up such a fuss. I was just curious. OK, back to state cup.
ReplyDeleteI have noticed that no one has mentioned Cottage Grove or TC Fire. Cottage Grove was one of the last 4 teams in the state cup semi finals for U14 (current U15 this year). 2 MTA teams, PL and CG.
Always a few laughs on here.
ReplyDeleteI'm guessing that the 15 semi's will be: PL, Cottage Grove, MTA and Tonka.
Cottage Grove lost top scorer to MTA ECNL, but my understanding is that they did gain some TC Fire girls? So they could still be strong this year.
Here's a good question:
ReplyDeleteIf MTA does not win any state cups this year, does anyone think they may bring back all of their ECNL teams next year to compete?
Not sure? But, no worries, they'll win at 13, 15 and 17.
ReplyDelete2:08, You are silly.
ReplyDelete3:16, You are such a bully.
ReplyDelete2:08pm Here. I don't care if 3:16pm thinks I'm silly. And I don't think they're a bully. Maybe I'm silly or maybe I'm completely off my rocker, but MTA will win 13, 15 and 17.
ReplyDelete3:50, you are correct. It appeared as if I was being a bully. I should have said that I think their position/belief (that MTA will win 13, 15, and 17) is silly-thanks.
ReplyDeleteMTA will win 13 & 15, not sure about 17. You can take that to the bank!
ReplyDeleteMTA 13, 15 and 17 will not win. Anyone who thinks otherwise, knows nothing.
ReplyDeleteSo 9:42am enlighten us with who you do think will win those age groups?
ReplyDelete9:42am. I respect your opinion, but I'm curious who do you think will win those age groups and why.
ReplyDeleteHere's my reason why I think MTA will win 15 & 17.
15 MTA - semi's last year, lost to PL 2-1. The team is stronger tha they've ever been. Played their ECNL team to a 0-0 game for most of the game, but lost 1-0 late in the game when SB powered one in.
17 MTA - picked up a few players from the TCF team that went to semi's last year. Also stronger than they've ever been.
What do you know 9:42am?
ReplyDelete13 mta or rev
ReplyDelete14 psa, mu or centennial
15 pl tonka mta or rev
16 St croix psa rev or ep
17 mta wayzatta Burnsville or St
18 ssm
the coaches from mta ecnl teams don't care about state cup. They will not come back until girls stop showing up at tryouts. Until then they could care less (and this is from a mta parent!)
ReplyDeleteMYSA changed around the U15 state cup brackets. Now, A plays D and B plays C for semi finals.
ReplyDeleteWhy the change? How are they determined anyway?
ReplyDeleteMYSA did change the U15 semi's around, but they were wrong before. Look at years past - A winner plays D winner and B plays C.
ReplyDeleteBesides, top seed is in A, 2nd seed in B, 3rd seed in C and than there was D (no seed, draw only). Shouldn't A play D and B play C?
So it will be PL (A) vs Tonka (D)
Cottage Grove (B) vs MTA (C).
Final - PL vs MTA
Winner - MTA in a close one
Doesn't matter who Tonka plays in semi's. They'll beat everyone to win it all.
ReplyDelete18 scrimmage last night ssm 1 St. Croix 0
ReplyDeleteThe dark horse at u15 that no one talks about is NSSA. They are quietly waiting in the weeds ...
ReplyDeleteBig break for MTA. PL and Tonka will beat each other up in the Semi's.
ReplyDeleteNot taking anything away from NSSA, but I don't think they have a snowball's chance in hell. It's great that they moved up to the premier league, but now they're playing much bigger, stronger and faster teams than they played at C1 in the north league.
ReplyDeleteAre you assuming 10:02am that MTA will make semi's?
ReplyDelete10:09 - yes, MTA will make the semi's.
ReplyDeleteMTA 15's will make the finals.
ReplyDeleteDon't put any stock in the SSM/SCV scrimmage. SCV was missing 4 key players.
ReplyDeleteNSSA U15 scrimmaged Dakota Alliance U15 in Sioux Falls about 10 days ago. Anyone know the score?
ReplyDeleteMTA 15s will not win. Too much hype on this blog from parents who wish their kids were on the ECNL team.
ReplyDelete10:08 AM I choose to tell you who will not win
ReplyDelete"NSSA U15 scrimmaged Dakota Alliance U15 in Sioux Falls about 10 days ago. Anyone know the score"?
ReplyDeleteI don't know but I'm sure one or both of them were "missing players".
ECNL is not for everyone. People do chose not to play ECNL?
ReplyDeleteHere's my prediction on how U17's will go down:
ReplyDeleteBracket A Winner: TCF
Bracket A Runnerup: EDP
Bracket B Winner: WYZ
Bracket B Runnerup: BVL
Semi #1 (TCF vs. BVL): TCF
Semi #2 (WYZ vs. EDP): WYZ
Final (TCF vs. WYZ): TCF
SCV could be a dark horse in the B bracket though, we'll see how they fair in MRL and maybe I'll change my picks. Nice to see so many of these teams playing MRL, makes for a better state cup tournament instead of coming in cold.
TCF lost too many players to make it out of bracket play.
ReplyDeleteTCF is still looking for players for their U17 premier according to the player exchange on the MYSA website.
ReplyDeleteTCF is still looking for players for their U17 premier according to the player exchange on the MYSA website.
ReplyDeleteTonka 15s will struggle unless they make some position changes. They have their best play makers playing defense when they should be playing in the mid or attack.
ReplyDeleteThat strategy can work well. Defend (pack the box) and get one or two break - a - ways.
ReplyDeleteThanks 6:24 who must be the Dad of the Tonka player on denfense who should be playing forward?
ReplyDeleteI love it -- do parents really think that by venting on a blog they will get their way? Try talking to your kid's coach about it, that just might be a bit more effective and enlightening for you! But, good luck with it, I'm sure your coach is an avid reader of this blog and will adjust his/her system as soon as possible.
ReplyDeleteTC Fire will not win U-17. Burnsville will win this age group. They are IMO clearly the best team at U-17 now that MTA ECNL is not in the mix.
ReplyDelete6:24pm. That might be all you need to get by PL in the semi's. Not alot of offense on the PL side.
ReplyDelete9:49 PM -- why do you assume that?
ReplyDelete13's REV
ReplyDelete14's CNS
15's MTA
16's EDP
17's BVL
18's SCV
That's my winners!
For the 15's don't under estimate anyone it could very well be and of the 5 most talented teams who are very well matched. It could either be MTA, PL, Tonka, Rev, or Cottage Grove. With out the ECNL MTA's this year it's anyones game.
ReplyDeleteAgree 9:19pm, but REV is a long shot up against the other four teams.
ReplyDeleteREV beat PL last year and beat Cottage Grove this winter not sure if they have played MTA and or Tonka.
ReplyDeleteMore importantly they added numerous quality players at tryouts and have been going three times a week all winter and they have a very good coach.
Guess I like the long shot to at least be in the semi =)
When did REV beat PL last year? And yes they did beat CG this winter, but CG was playing without a goalie. Still, I would give them chance.
ReplyDeleteREV beat PL in the Championship game of the Walmart Cup. They also beat a very good TC Fire team twice last year.
ReplyDelete9:47,
ReplyDeleteEveryone knows REV only has a couple quality coaches and HE is not one of them.